p400 said:
Thanks Bill, Good pictures. It looks like the Ranger chrome fender you show was using the same rubber bush mounting, yes?
What diameter are these grommet holes in the P11A alloy fender you show and compare to Ranger chrome fender.....consistent dimension?
I am having difficulty in picking out this grommet detail from period P11 photos....so it is possible the rear mudguard grommet use was introduced after the first batch of P11 were trialed.
Do you have running length dimension on the P11A rear alloy section please?
Sorry, house is upside down right now and can't get to the fender. Regardless of the year, the rear fender should start about 9 inches past the rear loop and end at the front of the front tabs (pretty much at the rear of the seat on a P11, about 2 inches under the seat on a P11A, and almost midway under the seat to the one front tab on a Ranger.
The back of the fender should end an inch or so below the bottom of the license bracket on a P11 (big black thing, same as an Atlas), or an inch or so below the license plate on a P11A or Ranger (They use the cast aluminum piece with side reflectors)
The fender sides will be rolled and the ends simply cut, with the rear cut running roughly parallel to the ground. Front cut should be perpendicular to the ground on a P11/P11A, and parallel to the ground on a Ranger
Grommet is about 1/2" outer diameter and 1/4" inner. Rather than grommets, I assembled mine with neoprene washers. I didn't know about the grommets until after I finished the bike, but figured I needed to do something to prevent cracking. My bike showed about 16,000 miles on it, and all five mounting holes (Rangers have one more) had radial cracks. The cross brace on my rear loop was replaced with 1/8" steel by the original owner, as the original gage steel had obviously broken off. The original rear fender is still on my bike, cracks welded and rechromed.
These bikes were all built in a period of about 20 months, and problem pieces, like fenders and oil tanks, were changed continuously. I spoke to one owner of an early P11 who had his rear fender replaced a few times and the front once before the dealer switched to chromed steel. He also had his alloy oil tank replaced with steel.