I’m a bit confused by what you’re saying.
you asked what’s the best non norton. Many bikes have great characteristics and joys. When comparing a modern bike to a Norton, all others are better, their is no new Norton to be had.
Well, you asked, so here goes. Although, to be honest, having two yourself, I thought you’d get ‘it’ more than most!
For me, the joy of the 961 was its character. Every ride was an ‘event’. A real visceral, sense tingling experience. Or, in another word: FUN !
By comparison almost every modern bike (in my personal opinion at least) feels stale by comparison unless your doing 170mph+, irrespective of how good they actually are (and there’s no argument there, they are all awesomely good).
Also, many modern bikes offer utterly unnecessary performance that is inaccessible to 99% of riders 99% of the time. Having to constantly try and tame this ridiculous performance, constantly be in fear of unwittingly riding at twice the legal limit, or having to ride the thing outside of its designed ‘zone’ just isn’t fun riding in my book.
So, my original quest was for a bike that compared favourably with the Norton for ‘character’ and ‘fun’ and yet also offered more performance and reliability at the same time, but not necessary 200mph plus license, life or liberty taking performance !
I thought I’d found a good balance with the Monster 1200S. Compared to your average in line 4 it seemed very characterful. But I hardly rode it. I rode my Brit bikes instead. My conclusion is that however good it was, it just didn’t make each ride into the kind of character filled ‘event’ that I was looking for.
I‘m not arguing against sports bikes per se, those that want one should buy one as they’ve NEVER been so damned good, and probably won’t be for ever either. But for those that don’t, for those that want Norton 961 character without buying a Norton 961, what are the best options.
That‘s the question as best as I can describe it.