BillT said:
If an ignoble reason is to win races, then they were guilty.
The N/G15 was not built to win any races, it was just a way to increase production numbers to try and keep up with BSA/Triumph who had many times the sales.
The P11 was designed in the USA by someone who knew what they were doing and was a much better idea for off-road use.
American riders were such that they would have raced anything that was available and they did just that. So they deserve any credit, not AMC or Berliner who were simply interested in sales and money.
Featherbed Dominators were very successfully raced on dirt, for instance call up Kenny Hayes, he and his brother Jim won many dirt events with featherbed Manxman/Atlas bikes including a grueling race called the "Southern 500", yes a 500 mile long dirt race which they won on featherbed bikes three or four years in a row.
Racers won off-road and scrambles events on Harley Davidson Sportsters as often or more so than any Norton did, and BSA and especially Triumph did the bulk of winning and sales in their class. This says much less about the bikes than the riders who were resisting change to 2-stroke technology and who wrestled 3-400 pounds of iron for the duration of any event. Men of steel.
Ludwig I applaud your purchase and use of the N15 over the last decades. You have found what it is best suited for. You would agree that any similarly prepared classic including a featherbed framed or Matchless twin engined bike with comparable modern upgrades by a smart and dedicated owner would certainly do the same job.
The AMC hybrids have their place in history as do all the obsolete machinery marketed in the late 60s, but they are certainly not from or representative of the golden age of the British Motorcycle industry or outstanding in any way compared to their contemporaries. I will never disrespect someone like Ludwig or all the other forgotten souls who bought them new, and I already said that if it is what you have and you enjoy it then good for you. I simply reserve the right to say they are not my cup of tea and share what information I have concerning them.