Personal preferences, marque loyalty, perceptions of power and speed along with poor comparisons between bikes (your apple v my apple) make it nigh on impossible to reach any meaningful conclusion In such debates. They are fun though
My2P - we are trying to compare a Granny Smith with a Golden Delicious (I like both by the way) when comparing the Thruxton R to the 961. Despite my protestations of speed and power earlier I (and I suspect most others) did not buy the 961 based on outright performance. Who chooses an 80 hp, air cooled, push rod, parallel twin with 70 year old engine design technology if looking for performance. If you doubt the design heritage of the 961 start the engine, stand back and watch the front end jump up and down whilst on the side stand. Know of a modern bike that does that. The 961 is just not a modern bike, performance purchase. Hand built and as close to a classic/heritage machine as you can get from a new (ish) build? Not even sure it fits the Modern Classic genre.
The Thruxton R on the other hand is a modern, machine made, mass manufactured bike, built with outright performance as well as styling in mind. It is a modern sports bike in classic clothing. It highlights cooling fins, whilst hiding the radiator. It hides the fuel injection behind mock carbies etc etc. I guess a true modern classic. A great bike with great performance but for me, just another modern vanilla machine, and one that is not made in the UK despite leaning very heavily on its British heritage for marketing. That matters to me!
For me the Norton is a genuine British bike and yes, we know containing some foreign components - maybe more than we would like. It is built in the UK by British workers. That matters to me and if that changes I will not feel the same about the marque. I love the history of Norton, it’s racing pedigree and it’s cafe racer connections. It is not about power and 0-60 times, it’s about pride of ownership, character, exclusivity, individuality and patriotism. I just can’t get anything close to that from a modern Triumph, I am sad to say. With all that said, I do not discount the performance of the 961. Sorted, and with carbon wheels fitted as mine is, I have no doubt that the 961 can at least match the Thruxton in the twisties! After all, that is where a Cafe Racer belongs.
PS. Oh yeh! And the 961 is f#@*^g beautiful!
Long live Norton.