I've always believed that the black tail light fairing came in with the introduction of the Roadster in 1970, but I have seen some examples with metalflake silver fairings. I can't recall seeing an 'S' Type with a black fairing though.
Interesting comment regarding yellow bikes - All the 'S' Type survivors I've seen have been metalflake; predominantly Royal Blue, followed by Red and Emerald Green.
My understanding is for '69 only Blue & Red flake were available.
My May '70 'S' Type was originally Emerald Green (went to Elite Motors, London). No idea what colour the tail light fairing was as it's long gone.
Thank you for this info. In the US, we were told that the only choices available for a '69 "S" were the Ruby Red Fireflake and the Saphire/Pacific Blue Fireflake finishes. (It is possible is that others were available regularly in other markets.) At the same time, there were "plain metalflake" silver Commandos (later called "Fastback" models) or silver with a translucent top coat applied over (or applied first into a mold if for a gelcoated glassfibre tank). The "R" models might have had blue available but the only ones I've seen photographed "modern" or period were red fireflake. My first Commando was a '69 "S" -- engine number approx. 500 after the quoted "S" built -- with Ruby Red paint; I had seen photos of the blue and was told that it was late coming to the market and so only red was available at the time. On later trips to my dealer, I did see blue "S" models in stock.
I am only guessing but it may have been that there were production holdups with the blue and, although both red and blue were shown and quoted to be available for '69, in practice, only red was available for a short time during the early days; perhaps, the "R" was planned for blue but it never happened. Again, only guesses and my dealer may have been trying to sell a red one that he had on his floor and was trying to deflect a buyer's wish for a blue one.
There was a lot of turmoil about the "S" in the spring of 1970. The major US distributor was very distressed about the very high warranty costs on the "S" - mostly exhaust problems - and urged that the model be replaced by something else. OTOH, the "S" was a huge sales success and a major market changer. It appears to me that the "S" was going to carry over to the '70 production year but the axe fell suddenly when the Roadster became available.
Also, at just that time, there were major increases in the finish colours of the Roadster; for '70, there were yellow, red, and black (solid colours), and Royal Blue, Roman Purple, Golden Bronze, Emerald Green metalflakes (and a Tangerine solid for H*-R*d*rs only). I assume that those metal flakes were Fireflake process - all at this time were glassfibre tanks and side covers.
Uncertainty comes when trying to ascertain whether any or many '70 "S" models were produced with the wider range of finish colors. My impression (have been working at several Norton dealers in the early '70s and later at the Wolverhampton factory) is that the Ruby Red was due to die with the "S", the Sapphire/Pacific Blue was to continue for Roadsters as the "Royal Blue" and that *normally* the last of the "S" models were not to get the newer, wider range of colours. However, we know that there were some "S" models delivered in '70 with the newer colours, (as I mentioned before, oddly, it was likely that these were individual motorcycles after the regular "S" production run was due to have ended). It may have been that the distributors allowed favored (??) dealers to place special orders for late "S" motorcycles in the '70 Roadster colours.
It may have also been that the paint components for the Royal Blue were changed to to a more normal (and less expensive) plan metalflake type paint. The "flake" blue was carried over to the steel Roadster tanks at the end of '72/ early '73 as steel tanks and side covers were brought into production, but this was, indeed, non-Fireflake blue metalflake paint specification, not the more expensive Fireflake.
Since the Roadster went to a black taillamp fairing, it might be likely that those late '70 "S" motorcycles in colours more commonly used on Roadster might get the black fairing in '70 but I have no info to verify this.