Hi Britfan , Are you asking why not use a100% non-synthetic oil ? Yes you can BUT , the synthetics have been shown to perform better and last longer. Perform better in the high and low temperature extremes (stays thicker when its hot and more fluid when its cold) . This protects the engine parts from metal to metal contact. And longer lasting in that it stays in grade longer and fights the effect of fuel and contaminate dilution. The process of shearing the molecules apart between tight surfaces like gear teeth and cam lobe to tappets . A non-synthetic oil will shear out of grade faster than a synthetic. The oils typically shear down and become thinner so to speak. There are many aspects to oil testing and this just scratches the surface. Are synthetic oils better YES , in every respect except cost. I think the answer to your question then is YES engine life only. Also , lets not forget that Norton are expecting to get 6,000 miles between oil changes and to achieve that synthetics are mandatory.