I have three differant O Ring primary gaskets, Two that are new from Old Britts & one that was in this 850 when I bought it. That one is ever so slightly larger in thickness and much softer then the two new ones that are just a tad thinner but way harder. Since it didn't leak I'm inclined to reuse the old one which is something I would never do other any other circomstances but it seems like I would be foolish to mess with something that works. Have you guys noticed that the soft ones seal better or has anyone else even noticed any differance in them at all ? By the way there was just a hint of some gasket sealer on the face of the cover flat that touches the O Ring, none in the groove. It was so slight I didn't think there was any at first but saw just a light film when I cleaned the cover. What's the best, Soft & slightly thicker or Hard and badly noticably thinner??