I have used POR 15 in several steel tanks. I would never use it in a fiberglass tank. One is going on ten years, the others are closing in on 5. No problems whatsoever - they look as good as the day I finished them. If it's "rubbish", well, you learn a lot on these forums. As much as I hestitated to jump in on a tank sealing thread, I only use tank sealers to provide a coating on the inside of the tank, not to fix any leaks. BMW and Harley both coated the inside of their steel tanks in years gone by. I was always amazed how good some of those tanks looked after many years. That's the reason I use this stuff, no other. Keeps rust from forming, especially on the top surface of the tank. I live in an area with high humidity, and that's a problem. I also know that if I have to weld any of these tanks, I'll just go to the radiator shop and get them boiled out, and start over on paint, etc.